Skip to content
Delivery
Search
Search
Start typing, then use the up and down arrows to select an option from the list.
Go to
Business
Account
Deals & Sale
Prepared & Deli
Produce
Meat & Poultry
Seafood
Dairy
Beverages
Bakery
Frozen
Grocery
Wine & Spirits
Seasonal
Dairy
Dairy
Butter & Margarine
Margarine
I Can't Believe It's Not Butter Spray
Shop all I Can't Believe It's Not Butter
Sold out
Description
Nutrition
Ingredients
Like that? You’ll Love This
slide 1 of 1
I Can't Believe It's Not Butter
Original Vegetable Oil Spread
current price
$6.99/ea
$7.46/lb
15oz
Brummel & Brown
Spread
current price
$6.79/ea
$6.79/lb
15oz
Express
Land O'Lakes
Unsalted Butter
current price
$7.19/ea
$7.19/lb
4ct, 4oz ea
Horizon Organic
Salted Butter
current price
$12.59/ea
$12.59/lb
4ct, 4oz ea
Frequently bought together!
slide 1 of 2
Brothers Ridge
Local Butterflied Leg of Lamb, Whole, Pasture-Raised
current price
$25.19/lb
Brothers Ridge
Local Lamb Leg Cubes, Pasture-Raised
current price
$21.49
Save 62%
buy
$8/lb for 3lb or more
1.00lb
$21.49/lb
Ocean Perch Fillet
current price
$18.99/lb
(min. of 2)
4-6 OZ
Levy's
Real Jewish Rye Bread, Seedless
current price
$5.59/ea
$5.59/lb
16oz, 14 slices ea
Chobani
Less Sugar Greek Yogurt, Madagascar Vanilla & Cinnamon
current price
$8.29/ea
$5.53/lb
32oz
Just FreshDirect
Boneless Center-Cut Turkey Breast, Raised w/o Antibiotics
current price
$12.99/lb
Bilinski's
All-Natural Chicken Sausage, Spinach & Garlic
current price
$7.69/ea
$10.25/lb
12oz
Boar's Head
Low Sodium Lacey Swiss Cheese
current price
$7.25
0.50lb
$14.49/lb
Hellmann's
Light Mayonnaise
current price
$7.19/ea
$3.82/pt
30fl oz
current price $21.49Save 62%buy$8/lb for 3lb or more1.00lb$21.49/lb
