A Valentine's steak dinner for two

Recreate the steakhouse for an at-home date night with luscious beef and a few of the classic sides. All you need to do is season your favorite cut with salt and pepper, sear it to your preferred doneness, then serve with a simple sauce - we love a compound butter with lemon, garlic, and fresh herbs but you can find complete recipes on our blog. Add on a few of our chef-prepped sides to make your meal complete, then break out your good plates and the candlelight.
Prime Reserve Local Angus RWA Rib Eye Steak
Prime ReserveLocal Angus RWA Rib Eye Steak
current price $25.99/lb
1.5" thick
Local Angus RWA Filet Mignon
Local Angus RWAFilet Mignon
current price $11.25
0.31lb$35.99/lb
Prime Reserve Local Angus RWA NY Strip Steak, Boneless
Prime ReserveLocal Angus RWA NY Strip Steak, Boneless
current price $19.80
Thick (approx. 1.5") 0.90lb$22.00/lb
Bison Rib Eye Steak
Bison Rib Eye Steak
current price $19.99/ea
approx. 10oz
Prime Reserve Local Angus RWA Bone-In Rib Steak
Prime ReserveLocal Angus RWA Bone-In Rib Steak
current price $23.74
0.95lb$24.99/lb
100% Grass-Fed Local NY Strip Steak, Boneless
100% Grass-Fed LocalNY Strip Steak, Boneless
current price $12.99 Save 50%
buy$10/lb for 2lb or more
0.65lb$19.99/lb
Prime Reserve Local Angus RWA Frenched Bone-In Rib Chop
Prime ReserveLocal Angus RWA Frenched Bone-In Rib Chop
current price $26.99/lb
approx. 1"-1.5" thick
Bison Sirloin Tip Steak
Bison Sirloin Tip Steak
current price $12.99/ea
approx. 7oz
100% Grass-Fed Local Filet Mignon
100% Grass-Fed LocalFilet Mignon
current price $12.50
0.31lb$39.99/lb
Hickory Nut Gap Pork Rib Eye Chops, Pasture-Raised Heritage
Hickory Nut GapPork Rib Eye Chops, Pasture-Raised Heritage
current price $5.25

(min. of 2)

0.50lb$10.49/lb
Hickory Nut Gap Bone-In Pork Loin Rib Chop, Pasture-Raised Heritage
Hickory Nut GapBone-In Pork Loin Rib Chop, Pasture-Raised Heritage
current price $7.99
1.5" thick 0.80lb$9.99/lb
100% Grass-Fed Local Rib Eye Steak
100% Grass-Fed LocalRib Eye Steak
current price $10.49
0.50lb$20.99/lb
FreshDirect Almost Perfect Mashed Potatoes
FreshDirectAlmost Perfect Mashed Potatoes
current price $10.99/ea
$5.50/lb2lbs
FreshDirect Fingerling Potatoes with Herbs
FreshDirectFingerling Potatoes with Herbs
current price $5.99/ea
$9.49/lb10.1oz
FreshDirect Rosemary-Garlic Roasted New Potatoes
FreshDirectRosemary-Garlic Roasted New Potatoes
current price $10.99/ea
$7.33/lb24oz
Satur Farms Local Sage, Rosemary, and Thyme Herb Trio
Satur FarmsLocal Sage, Rosemary, and Thyme Herb Trio
current price $3.99/ea
approx. 2oz
Italian Parsley
Italian Parsley
current price $1.29/ea
approx. 4oz
Garlic
Garlic
current price $1.99/ea
3ct, approx. 3.2oz